May I ask for your guidance?
"May I ask your name?"
Zhang Haochu was certainly aggressive, headstrong, and lawless, but he was no fool. In fact, those who studied were rarely foolish; the dull-witted would have long since starved. Seeing that even the overbearing Zeng Yuanshu had backed down, Zhang realized that the young man before him must hold significant influence within the Zeng family. Despite his youth, Zhang immediately adopted the polite tone of a scholar and offered a formal bow.
"I am Zeng Xingwu from Huguang, a kinsman of Yuanshu. I am aware of the conflict between my cousin and you. In my opinion, it would be best for both sides to cease this struggle and avoid bringing physical harm upon the servants..."
Wei Guangde watched from the side, stunned as Zeng Xingwu stepped forward to negotiate with Zhang Haochu. *Can this really work?*
"He is a Xiucai (a licentiate)," whispered Wu Dong, perhaps sensing Wei Guangde’s astonishment.
The words were like a bucket of cold water, instantly clearing Wei’s mind. He realized that Zhang Haochu’s apprehension was indeed rooted in that status. In the Ming Dynasty, a Xiucai held special privileges. What commoner would dare strike one? They wouldn't even dare to insult one. With Zeng simply standing there, Zhang Haochu’s side dared not make a move, for the consequences were clearly too severe.
In later literature, the image of the "poor scholar" often prevailed—the idea that when a scholar met a soldier, his reason would fall on deaf ears. Influenced by these works, people often perceived scholars as both destitute and weak. While they were indeed poor compared to the wealthy, they were far from powerless among the common folk. They were "weak" in terms of physical strength, but they possessed immense political privilege.
In truth, whether in the Ming or Qing dynasties, a Xiucai held considerable influence in local affairs and no one dared to bully them. The smaller the locale, the greater this influence. If a precedent for assaulting a scholar were set, the entire scholarly community would rise up as one to make an example of the offender. Even if a Xiucai were to be bullied, it could only be done by someone of equal or higher academic standing.
Was Zeng Xingwu’s status sufficient? Certainly. Given that those present were merely youths in their teens or twenties, his degree was more than enough. While the Zhang family was also prominent, the Zengs were no pushovers. Zhang Haochu’s father was a Xiucai, but the Zeng family had their own, and Zeng Yuanshu’s grandfather was a Juren (a provincial graduate), though he was now too old to move about.
If this had been a simple brawl, it might not have mattered much. But if this Xiucai from another province were to take the matter to the authorities... Zhang Haochu felt a chill. Some things could be done but never spoken of, and certainly never brought before a magistrate. As long as it remained an unwritten rule and didn't reach the county office, there was room for maneuver. Once it involved a man with an academic degree, things became difficult.
Wei Guangde had previously known that scholars were powerful—and civil officials even more so—but this was his first time witnessing it firsthand. A single Xiucai standing there had effectively dissolved a fight that was on the verge of erupting.
***
"Brother Zeng, I wonder if you have any model examination essays? I would like to study them more closely."
After the banquet resumed, the atmosphere remained subdued. Wei Guangde took the opportunity to state the purpose of his visit to Zeng Yuanshu.
"You wish to see those papers? Yes, I have quite a few. We have collected exam papers from previous sessions, from the prefectural examinations to the provincial, and even the metropolitan exams. As long as they are available in Jiujiang Prefecture, our family has them." Zeng Yuanshu understood; in this era, it was standard practice for scholars to study past papers to grasp the nuances of the examinations.
"Actually, Guangde, it is a bit early for you to start studying these contemporary essays. You should focus more on the annotations of the Four Books and other classics. Once you have thoroughly understood those, you can practice writing more in the year leading up to the exam," Zeng Xingwu interjected.
Zeng had little impression of this young boy and had said little during the meal, but hearing that the boy intended to dive into a vast quantity of contemporary essays, he felt compelled to offer a reminder based on his own experience: the Four Books and Five Classics were the foundation, and writing technique was merely the embellishment. A complete understanding of the sages' teachings was the root of one’s standing.
"I am grateful for your instruction," Wei Guangde replied with a bow.
Wei had his own plan. He intended to finish reading the Five Classics this year while concurrently studying the Four Books. When he grew tired of reading, he would write an eight-legged essay, which would both improve his calligraphy and familiarize him with writing techniques—a perfect strategy. Though he didn't know when Master Sun would let him sit for the county exam, he believed that if he could produce high-quality essays, the master would soon arrange for him to test his mettle.
Later, Wei Guangde and Zeng Yuanshu agreed on a time for him to visit, primarily to collect some of these essays. His cousin, Wu Dong, had already helped him find two impoverished scholars to help transcribe them. Indeed, most of these essays were kept in hand-copied manuscripts, though some were printed in collections by bookstores—a privilege usually reserved for provincial or metropolitan exam papers.
Wei Guangde knew that for his current level, prefectural exam papers were the most practical. However, since Zeng Xingwu was willing to offer guidance, Wei took every chance to continue asking questions. Through their conversation, Wei vaguely sensed that this young Xiucai’s knowledge might even surpass that of his own teacher, Master Sun, which only made him more eager to engage in discussion.
For the others present, talking with Zeng was an exchange of views, but for Wei, it was a quest for knowledge. While many questions regarding the Four Books and Five Classics had already been "perfectly" resolved by earlier sages, some interpretations varied, and it was a matter of whom one chose to believe.
Wei’s questions gradually shifted. At first, they were conventional, but upon realizing that Zeng Xingwu was an independent thinker, Wei began to lean toward his own perspectives—perspectives influenced by his future knowledge, which grew increasingly distinct from the contemporary consensus. Wei was not looking to promote modern ideologies; he was probing, considering how to handle policy questions in future provincial or metropolitan exams. He had to be careful about what could be written, and this was the perfect opportunity to test the waters with a genuine scholar.